Compliance & Policy
American Samoa groups sue over first U.S. deep-sea mining leases
Finafinau and NRDC seek to void a Nov. 19 sale of about 31.5 million acres of American Samoa seabed, citing an unlawful federal environmental review process.

Waypoints
A Nov. 19 lease sale covers about 31.5 million acres off American Samoa.
The proposed leases would last at least 20 years; Guam and the Northern Mariana Islands are next in line.
More than 76,000 public comments were filed, with the overwhelming majority opposing the proposal.
American Samoa banned deep-sea mining in its territorial waters in 2024.
A federal district judge already ruled the lease sale’s Endangered Species Act consultation unlawful.
A Nov. 19 lease sale would make about 31.5 million acres of federal seabed off American Samoa available to mining companies, the first such sale in U.S. history. It would open those waters to commercial deep-sea mining for the first time.
Finafinau, a youth-centered environmental group, and the Natural Resources Defense Council sued the Trump administration to block the sale. Their case in the U.S. District Court for the District of Hawaii argues that the Marine Minerals Administration cut the environmental review short. They seek to void any leases executed under the sale.
The proposed areas sit just beyond American Samoa’s territorial waters on the federal Outer Continental Shelf, next to the Rose Atoll Marine National Monument.
What does the sale change?
No deep-sea mine has operated at commercial scale. The Nov. 19 sale would put commercial deep-sea mining into U.S. waters for the first time.
Taryn Kiekow Heimer, NRDC’s director of Ocean Energy, said: “This sale is the blueprint for every one that comes after it.”
“These leases last at least 20 years. The Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands and Guam are next in line. If this goes through, the administration will have shown it can open the deep sea over the objections of the people who live closest to it.”
The practical effect is one sale now and two possible sales afterward.
Why is American Samoa opposed?
American Samoa’s governor, its legislature and its congresswoman oppose commercial deep-sea mining. More than 76,000 public comments were filed on the proposal, and the overwhelming majority opposed it. The territory banned deep-sea mining in its own waters in 2024.
Sabrina Suluai-Mahuka, founder of Finafinau, said:
“We had hoped we would never have to reach this point. Our communities have spoken, our leaders have voiced their opposition, and yet decisions about our ocean and our future continue to move forward without our meaningful consent.”
“Deep-sea mining is not for us. The ocean is not an empty space to be exploited for profit. It is our source of food, our cultural identity, our livelihood, and our connection to generations before and after us.”
“We cannot justify risking ecosystems we barely understand for an industry that offers no guarantees of safety, accountability, or meaningful benefits to our people. Ocean rights are human rights, because when you threaten the health of our ocean, you threaten the health, security, and future of our communities.”
“As a mother, an educator, and a daughter of American Samoa, I refuse to accept that our children should inherit the consequences of decisions they had no say in.”
“Finafinau did not choose this fight, but we will do everything within our power to protect our home and the future of our children. Our home is not for sale, and neither is their future.”
Broad opposition has not yet stopped the Nov. 19 sale.
What did the lawsuit challenge?
Finafinau and NRDC argue that the Marine Minerals Administration shortchanged the environmental review in what the complaint calls “a race to the bottom.” They cite four laws:
- Administrative Procedure Act
- National Environmental Policy Act
- Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act
- National Historic Preservation Act
A district judge has already ruled that the federal government’s Endangered Species Act consultation for the lease sale violated the law. The plaintiffs ask the court to strike down any leases executed under the sale.
The lawsuit attacks the legal process behind the leases, not only the policy of mining.
What risks come with the seabed?
The environmental stakes concern the seabed and polymetallic nodules:
- Commercial-scale deep-sea mining has never occurred.
- Removal would strip the seafloor much like clear-cutting a forest, send sediment plumes into the water column, and bring noise and light pollution to some of Earth’s quietest, darkest places.
- Polymetallic nodules take millions of years to form, and scientists continue to find new deep-sea species.
- Protected species in waters around American Samoa include sea turtles, whales, corals and sharks.
The unknowns are both legal and biological, which is a poor combination for an untested industry.
Who brought the challenge?
Finafinau is a grassroots, membership-based environmental organization grounded in Samoan cultural identity, resilience and intergenerational leadership. It centers young people and operates from American Samoa.
NRDC, established in 1970, works to safeguard Earth, people, plants, animals and natural systems on which all life depends. Its team includes more than 800 lawyers, policy experts, scientists, economists and communications specialists working in the United States and worldwide. Its offices include Washington, D.C., New York, Chicago, San Francisco, Santa Monica and Beijing.
NRDC also operates through its wholly owned for-profit subsidiary, NRDC India Private Limited, for an affiliate office in New Delhi and through UK-based partner NRDC International for a London office. The plaintiffs pair a local membership organization with an established environmental law and science group.
What decides the next step?
The next milestone is judicial: the District of Hawaii must rule on the plaintiffs’ request to strike down leases executed under the sale. Nov. 19 remains the administration’s planned sale date.
Speed has supplied a date. Consent has not.
via nrdc.org (Source)
More from Olivia Hart
Show full bio
Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on Circular economy and the environmental industry at Circular Wire.
550 articles