Survey
Cop31 Draft Drops 'Fossil Fuels' as Talks Enter Overtime
Cop31's latest draft cuts contested issues from 140 to 79 but deletes 'fossil fuels' entirely, replacing it with a weaker 'irreversible global transition' pledge as Panama threatens to block any deal.
Waypoints
Draft text issues cut from more than 140 on Monday to 79 in the Thursday draft
Words 'fossil fuels' removed; 'transition away from fossil fuels' replaced by 'irreversible global transition'
Last Cop to finish on time was Italy in 2003, per Carbon Brief
Panama formally objects unless eight conditions, including capping oil production, are met
First Cop to admit the 1.5C Paris goal would be breached; Pacific states want it kept alive
The final draft text at Cop31 in Antalya has cut the issues under negotiation from more than 140 on Monday to 79, while removing the words "fossil fuels" entirely — and the talks are almost certain to run past their scheduled close.
Turkey, the host, and Australia, president of the negotiations, had pushed for a "cover decision": an overarching agreement setting the direction of travel on climate action, energy investment, science, climate finance and adaptation worldwide. The latest draft landed yesterday afternoon. It is unlikely to land gently.
The last Cop to finish on time was Italy in 2003, according to Carbon Brief. Delegates should expect to still be in Antalya on Saturday, and possibly Sunday. The Guardian's liveblog is running from London, with colleagues on the ground guiding readers through the conclusion.
What does the new draft actually say?
The text was derided by observers for expunging the phrase "fossil fuels" while inserting "carbon capture and storage" — a technology the fossil fuel industry has promoted for decades while delivering almost nothing at scale.
The hoped-for commitment to "transition away from fossil fuels" was replaced with a weaker pledge of an "irreversible global transition" to lower emissions and climate resilience. The words are fewer. The obligations are vaguer.
This is also the first Cop to acknowledge that the 2015 Paris goal of working to limit global heating to 1.5C would be breached. Pacific countries want language that keeps that goal alive rather than presiding over its funeral.
The takeaway: the draft trades a specific commitment on fossil fuels for a general one on transition, and Pacific states are not prepared to let 1.5C slip quietly into the preamble.
Why is consensus the bottleneck?
The UN climate convention operates on consensus, meaning every party must agree. That protocol has been used in the past by high-emitting fossil fuel producers — Saudi Arabia and Russia chief among them — to slow and block progress.
Turkey and Australia now face the practically permanent divide between rich developed countries and fossil fuel producers on one side, and everyone else on the other. Bridging it across a whole suite of areas in a single day was never a realistic assignment.
What is Panama demanding?
Panama put a stake in the ground yesterday, writing formally to the Cop presidents to say it would object to any agreement that failed to satisfy eight issues. Its demands span:
- plans to protect biodiversity
- capping oil production at current levels
- forcing big emitting countries to provide finance
- changing the convention's voting rules to allow majority voting instead of consensus
The move turns the consensus rule on its head. For years it has served the blockers; now a small country is using the same veto logic to demand ambition. Whether that leverage holds through the final plenary is the question the closing session must answer.
The takeaway: Panama has converted a procedural formality into a bargaining position, and the presidency cannot gavel through a deal it does not like.
What happens next?
An on-time finish is not impossible, but nobody in the halls is betting on it. The variables are few and fixed: whether Turkey and Australia can shrink 79 contested issues into a text Panama will accept, whether Pacific states get their 1.5C language, and whether "irreversible global transition" survives contact with parties who wanted the words "transition away from fossil fuels" restored.
Watch the closing plenary. The milestone that decides everything is the final cover decision — and whether it arrives with consensus intact or over a formal objection.
via theguardian.com (Source)
More from Olivia Hart
Show full bio
Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on Circular economy and the environmental industry at Circular Wire.
550 articles