E-Scrap & Battery Recycling

E-scrap panel: only 15% of electronics collected as US chases minerals

E-Scrap Conference panelists say only 15% of US electronics get collected; Mint's Texas plant will process 4,500 tons of boards yearly while EPR laws draw mixed verdicts.

Inclusivity is key to building mineral supply, insiders say
Inclusivity is key to building mineral supply, insiders saypadrinan / pixabay

Waypoints

  1. Only 15% of US electronics produced today are collected for recovery, per Mint Innovation's Chris York.

  2. Mint Innovation's Longview, Texas facility will process 4,500 tons of circuit boards per year, double its Sydney capacity.

  3. ReElement's two Indiana plants were permitted in under two months, versus two to three years for solvent extraction permits.

  4. Washington State's solar panel EPR law drove five manufacturers out of the market, per Comstock's Cody Oliver.

  5. New Jersey's solar panel recycling law faces legal challenges, leaving panels in storage or hazardous waste landfills.

By Rebecca Stone

Only 15% of the electronics produced in the United States today get collected for recovery, and that gap now frames the country's push for domestic critical mineral supply. Executives from Comstock Metals, Mint Innovation and ReElement Technologies laid out the problem and their capacity answers at the E-Scrap Conference on Oct. 26 in New Orleans.

The panel's premise: the federal government is shifting policy to bolster domestic mineral supply, yet the United States still lacks the refining infrastructure to process all the minerals its companies produce. Chris York, vice president of business development at New Zealand-based Mint Innovation, put the market case plainly.

"We don't have the processing capabilities here in the US. Our demand is outpacing the supply," York said. "So what we're trying to do is create that sovereign supply chain for those critical minerals."

What capacity is actually being built?

Mint is building a facility in Longview, Texas, with a processing capacity of 4,500 tons of circuit boards per year — roughly double the throughput of its Sydney plant. The company's patented process grinds boards finely and uses sponge-like bacteria that absorb materials, yielding more minerals while consuming less energy than other recycling methods, York said. The process is already proven in a commercial closed loop: HP reuses copper that Mint recovers from circuit boards HP supplies.

"It can be a full domestic circular model for anyone's supply chain," York said.

Comstock Metals has taken a market-specific route in solar panel recycling. Cody Oliver, Comstock's new director of public policy and government affairs, said the company's proprietary process removes laminates from panel glass — a step many recyclers skip, discarding the aluminum, silicon, silver and other minerals bound inside. The process "removes those laminates naturally, turning them into basically water vapor and carbon dioxide," he said. The released metals come out clean enough to stay in the domestic supply chain.

ReElement Technologies, an Indiana company, licensed chromatographic separation technology from Purdue University researchers. Ben Kincaid, CEO of ReElement Technologies Africa, said the method retrieves high-purity metals from liquid solutions the way solvent extraction does, but with fewer chemicals, less water and less infrastructure. The permitting difference matters: facilities seeking environmental permits for solvent extraction in the US can wait two or three years, while ReElement's two Indiana plants were permitted in less than two months, he said.

Traditional solvent extraction remains largely controlled by Chinese companies. Kincaid said such innovations have helped meet "historic commercial and national security objectives."

Where does EPR help and where does it fail?

Regulation drew a mixed verdict from the panel. Oliver called extended producer responsibility necessary in many ways but complicating in practice. Washington State's solar panel law, he said, led five manufacturers to stop doing business there rather than comply — a result that contradicts the law's intent. A similar local EPR law in Niagara County, New York, drew comparable blowback.

New Jersey's solar panel recycling law shows a second failure mode. Legal challenges have left panels either sitting in storage or going to hazardous waste landfills while legislators work out what moves forward.

Oliver argued the sector has been through this before. Panel recycling "really falls in the same line that I think e-waste has gone in the EPR process: 'There's no way I can do this, right? This is going to be terrible,'" he said. "I think we need a lot of advocates in this space to say, 'Hey, we've done it before. We can do it again.'"

York pressed the collection point regardless of EPR design: "We're only collecting 15% of what's produced today anyway. So we still have a long way to go regardless of EPR." Oliver added that the industry's main competitors are the landfills it tries to divert material from, and that safe, cost-effective circulation channels will move more companies to participate.

Can a fragmented sector close the loop?

Kincaid described an ITAD sector of thousands of companies operating in differing ways, with no coherent funnel to reach needed volumes. "It's a very decentralized, fragmented space," he said. "There's not a coherent way of doing things to feed things into a funnel to get the volumes that are needed."

Flexibility is part of his answer. ReElement repurposes its processing columns for different mineral feedstocks. "Having technology that's adaptable and flexible, especially in volatile commodity cycles and with all the changes that we're going through, it's important," Kincaid said.

York said more US refineries like Mint's would speed manufacturing by ending round trips to Asia and Europe for mineral recovery. Kincaid said companies needing feedstock and companies looking to offload material should simply talk: "Are there ways that people can partner with you to help you collect some of those rare earths from their areas throughout the country strategically? Aggregation at scale, even with some of the biggest ITAD companies in the world, is not something that's been figured out yet."

The milestone to watch is the Longview plant's 4,500-ton-per-year capacity coming online, alongside New Jersey courts and legislators settling what its panel recycling law will actually require.

via resource-recycling.com (Source)

Share this article:

More from Rebecca Stone

Rebecca Stone

Show full bio

News editor covering companies, deals and strategy in Circular economy and the environmental industry at Circular Wire.

516 articles

Nearby routes

« Previous articleNext article »