Compliance & Policy
GHG Protocol Scope 2 Overhaul Stalls on Legacy PPAs and Hourly Matching
More than 1,100 comments failed to resolve hourly matching and legacy PPA treatment in the GHG Protocol's Scope 2 revision, with decisions due December 15.

Waypoints
Technical working group met Oct. 20–22 with 39 of 46 members to reconcile over 1,100 consultation comments on Scope 2 rules.
CEBA members hold more than 50 GW procured under current rules; a single effective date could strand 15-year PPAs.
Phased compliance timelines discussed run from 2031 to 2039, starting with loads above 10 TWh annually.
Recommendations go to the independent standards board in early December ahead of a Dec. 15 meeting; final text circulates Q2 2027.
SBTi's Corporate Net-Zero Standard 2.0 takes effect Feb. 1 and is seeking comments on interim Scope 2 bridge rules.
More than 1,100 public comments failed to settle the central questions hanging over the GHG Protocol's overhaul of its Scope 2 electricity accounting rules, leaving companies that have procured upward of 50 gigawatts of renewable capacity waiting on decisions due December 15.
A three-day technical working group meeting, held in Washington, D.C., and virtually from October 20–22, convened 39 of 46 members along with guests from the GHG Protocol's independent standards board, its secretariat and the International Organization for Standardization. The group was tasked with reconciling feedback submitted during the public consultation on the Scope 2 revision, which governs how companies calculate and disclose emissions inventories for purchased electricity. Notes summarizing the discussion were published this week.
The revision text as it currently stands would ask companies to report emissions from hourly electricity consumption rather than the annual calculation used under rules in place since 2015. It also introduces "deliverability" requirements that would force contracts or environmental attribute certificates to originate from the same regions where companies consume their power. Both proposals will appear in the final revisions, according to the meeting notes and an October 16 update from the independent standards board, which holds the final say.
What does this change for large power buyers? Potentially the accounting value of their entire contracted portfolio. Under the current text, a single effective date would require all contracts to meet new hourly matching, local deliverability and grid incrementality conditions — a structure that alarmed the Corporate Energy Buyers Association, whose members have procured more than 50 gigawatts under the existing rules.
"This means that a company that signed a 15-year PPA could lose credit for that investment while the PPA is ongoing," CEBA wrote in a blog detailing its concerns.
Where the working group landed
The hourly matching methodology may end up "recommended" rather than "required," phased in over several years starting with large electricity consumers as granular data becomes available, if the working group's recommendations carry through. Three adjustments drew support at the meeting:
- A phased transition beginning with the largest electricity users by load, with dates, thresholds and readiness conditions still undefined. Discussed timelines range from 2031 to 2039; companies with annual loads above 10 terawatt-hours may face compliance by 2031, based on 2030 data.
- Standardized grid boundaries grounded in "plausible physical connection between generation and consumption." The GHG Protocol or an independent authority would set the list, sparing companies from interpreting boundaries individually.
- Flexibility on incrementality, which the working group wants recommended rather than required. Likely to qualify: clean generation contracts where the corporate buyer is the original offtaker, or where the generation source falls within a certain age limit — 15 years was discussed.
Matthew Yamatin, a former Thermo Fisher Scientific sustainability program manager now working as an independent advisor, flagged the balance of power at the meeting. "What struck me, and what may be the bigger story, is how it appears the independent standards board has already decided the major items and is using the working group to discuss more technical points," he said.
The meeting summary itself counsels patience. "The outcomes of the workshop, as reflected in the minutes, are an interim step towards a final standard which will require additional steps and public consultation," it states.
The December milestone
Subgroups of the technical working group and further meetings planned through November will tackle the outstanding issues, including how lengthy legacy power purchase agreements are treated. Recommendations go to the independent standards board in early December, for consideration at its scheduled December 15 meeting.
Final revision text will circulate in the second quarter of 2027 as part of a comprehensive public consultation on a unified corporate carbon accounting standard jointly developed by the GHG Protocol and ISO.
The ripple effects are already reaching the Science Based Targets initiative. SBTi's Corporate Net-Zero Standard 2.0, which contains major changes to Scope 2 target-setting processes, takes effect February 1, and the initiative is now seeking public comments on potential interim changes — including definitions for grid deliverability regions and clarified recognition pathways for older PPAs — meant to bridge the gap until the GHG Protocol's corporate standard is finalized.
For corporate energy buyers, the December 15 board meeting will decide whether decade-long PPA portfolios retain their accounting value under the new regime, or whether the transition clock starts regardless.
via ghgprotocol.org (Original)
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Market editor covering money, funding and market shifts around Circular economy and the environmental industry at Circular Wire.
573 articles