Compliance & Policy

New coalition challenges BPI’s federal compostable packaging push

A new coalition challenges BPI’s federal push for compostable packaging as California’s June 2027 label deadline approaches and a 180-day standard meets 60-day processing.

BPI responds to organic compost coalition
BPI responds to organic compost coalitionAI-generated

Waypoints

  1. California’s AB 1201 is scheduled to take effect June 30, 2027.

  2. BPI permits up to 180 days for biodegradation; some commercial composters end processing after 60 days.

  3. USDA plans an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking early next year.

  4. Six compost operators signed a February letter supporting BPI’s USDA petition.

  5. California is by far the nation’s largest compost market.

By Rebecca Stone

California has scheduled AB 1201 to take effect June 30, 2027, sharpening a federal dispute over whether compostable packaging may enter compost used for organic agriculture.

The Biodegradable Products Institute, a trade group, is defending a yearslong push to allow compostable packaging in compost used for organic agriculture. BPI has petitioned the U.S. Department of Agriculture multiple times.

Its defense follows the launch last week of the Safer Soils for All Coalition, whose members include major haulers and the California Compost Coalition. The group argues that compostable packaging creates too many problems for composters.

BPI Executive Director Rhodes Yepsen said the coalition was “the waste industry dressed up in composter clothing.” He said BPI does not seek to require composters to accept compostable products. It wants the products permitted in compost used for organic agriculture, a key end market.

Who backs the federal petition?

The Safer Soils for All Coalition includes several commercial composters, but six other operators have supported BPI’s position: Black Earth Compost, Blue Earth Compost, Garbage to Garden, Earth Matter, Compost Now and Veteran Compost.

In February, those operators sent USDA a letter urging the agency to issue an interim final rule addressing the definition of compost. They said the rule would trigger a public comment period and build a robust administrative record.

USDA did not respond to a request for comment on BPI’s petition. The agency has indicated that it will gather more information through an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking early next year. Yepsen considers that step unnecessary, but BPI continues to press for regulatory changes.

What changes under California’s label law?

California is by far the nation’s largest compost market. AB 1201, passed in 2021, would forbid products not allowed for use in organic agriculture from using a “compostable” label. With the federal definition unsettled, packagers fear that almost every product developed as compostable could be barred from the label in California, cutting off a key market.

The state also requires businesses and households to separate organic waste at the curb. That requirement is increasing feedstock for composters and anaerobic digestion facilities. Some companies, including WM, have deployed organics processing equipment that accepts food waste largely from commercial businesses, turns it into slurry and sends the slurry to anaerobic digestion facilities.

Certain composters have also used slurry in their operations. Yepsen contends that this route can pass contaminants through to the finished product.

Does consumer confusion justify exclusion?

Stakeholders opposing wider compostable packaging say accepting it can create contamination because consumers do not understand what counts as compostable. Yepsen rejects that link between package acceptance and compost quality.

“Contamination is a major issue for composters, but I don’t see what’s allowed in organic agriculture or not have anything to do with contamination,” he said.

He attributes contamination to education and infrastructure, not to compostable products themselves. Yepsen also says the coalition is creating a distraction from large haulers’ investments in depackaging and processing equipment that produces agricultural products from slurry rather than compost. Those investments, he said, have nothing to do with organic farmers or compostable products.

Why do 180 days versus 60 days matter?

BPI allows products that can take up to 180 days to biodegrade to qualify as compostable. The coalition says that laboratory window is too long because some commercial composters end their process after 60 days. The laboratory period is three times the duration of that shorter commercial process.

Yepsen says the 180-day figure applies to laboratory conditions, while products typically break down much faster under commercial composting conditions. He argues that regulators should measure the stability and maturity of the compost itself rather than impose a fixed timeframe. The dispute therefore centers on the stability and maturity of finished compost rather than one fixed time limit.

What happens next?

USDA’s advanced notice of proposed rulemaking early next year is the next federal milestone. BPI wants an interim final rule sooner, while the coalition continues to oppose BPI’s advocacy.

California’s implementation date remains June 30, 2027, following a CalRecycle delay. Yepsen said CalRecycle can postpone the law again as the USDA process develops, and he said he hopes the agency does. The federal rulemaking and any further state delay will shape whether compostable packaging retains access to California’s organic-compost market.

via Waste Dive (Source)

Share this article:

More from Rebecca Stone

Rebecca Stone

Show full bio

News editor covering companies, deals and strategy in Circular economy and the environmental industry at Circular Wire.

540 articles

Nearby routes

« Previous articleNext article »