Compliance & Policy
WM, Republic and Recology Back Coalition Against Compostable Packaging in Organics
WM, Republic, Recology and others form Safer Soils for All to fight BPI's push for USDA to allow compostable packaging in organic compost feedstock.

Waypoints
NOSB rejected BPI's 2023 petition in January; BPI asked USDA in February for an interim final rule to bypass the board.
ASTM/BPI protocols allow 84 days for disintegration or 180 for biodegradation vs. 30-60 day commercial composting cycles.
CalRecycle pushed its compostable-labeling enforcement start to June 30, 2027, pending the federal determination.
Coalition members include WM, Republic Services, Waste Connections and Recology.
Some of the country's largest waste and composting companies — WM, Republic Services, Waste Connections, Recology — have formed a coalition to block federal approval of compostable packaging as an allowable feedstock in compost used on organic crops. The group, Safer Soils for All, launched in direct opposition to the Biodegradable Products Institute's push to get USDA to overrule its own advisory board.
The coalition's members span national haulers and regional California players: the California Compost Coalition, Napa Recycling and Waste Services, the Resource Recovery Coalition of California, the Rural County Representatives of California, and StopWaste.
What's the fight actually about?
The battleground is the National List of Allowed and Prohibited Substances, which governs what organic farmers can accept in soil amendments. In 2023, BPI petitioned USDA's National Organics Program to allow compost feedstocks meeting ASTM standards for biodegradability and compostability. BPI argued the change would accommodate an expanding biopolymer industry and help producers transition away from single-use plastics mandated out by various state laws.
The National Organics Standards Board commissioned a technical report and rejected the petition in January, determining that compostable products would not meet criteria on necessity, environmental and human health, and sustainable agriculture. USDA is not required to follow the board's guidance — and BPI knows it. In February, the institute called on USDA to issue an interim final rule that would allow compostable products, circumventing the NOSB determination entirely.
The list currently names only one packaging-like material: "newspapers or other recycled paper, without glossy or colored inks." It prohibits materials such as ash from manure burning, arsenic and calcium chloride. Compostable packaging appears nowhere.
Why are composters digging in?
Timing is one reason. The coalition notes ASTM and BPI testing protocols allow up to 84 days for disintegration or 180 days for biodegradation — far longer than the typical 30-to-60-day processing window at commercial compost facilities.
Contamination is the other. Neil Edgar, executive director of the California Compost Coalition, said composters who signal they'll take compostables see contamination rise as lookalike packaging that isn't compostable enters the feedstock. Some operators have stopped accepting the products altogether.
California's situation sharpens the stakes. Under SB 1383, the state has built a mature composting ecosystem with curbside food waste separation and large-scale commercial facilities. Those operations now produce enough finished compost to supply organic farmers — but only if their feedstock stays clean.
"They've been composting for more than two decades," Edgar said. "They've learned through experience that it's just very difficult to manage contamination if you're telling consumers to deliberately put packaging into the composting stream."
Does the whole industry agree?
Not entirely. Composters that already accept packaging — Black Earth Compost, Veteran Compost, Garbage to Garden, Earth Matter — plus packaging companies and trade groups signed a letter to USDA supporting BPI's petition. Edgar, who also holds a leadership role with the U.S. Composting Coalition, said operators in states without diversion mandates often take compostables to hit volume targets, and typically sell finished compost to landscapers rather than organic growers.
Safer Soils for All wants NOSB to evaluate synthetic substances individually for organic approval rather than grant a blanket allowance. "Compostable packaging is not one thing," Edgar said. He isn't opposed to the products themselves — "I'm a guy that's made my career on trying to keep material out of landfills," he said — but wants producers to fix compostability and identifiability questions first.
What happens next?
Watch California. Enforcement of the state's restriction on "compostable" labeling is tied to the federal determination, and CalRecycle has already pushed the start date to June 30, 2027. USDA's decision on BPI's interim-rule request — and whether it bypasses the NOSB — is the milestone that settles both questions.
via Waste Dive (Source)
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in Circular economy and the environmental industry at Circular Wire.
546 articles