Compliance & Policy
COP31 drags into overtime as second draft text halves the deal
COP31 ran past its official end with no final text. Panama threatens to block a deal without eight demands, and 100 NGOs call the draft "a gift to the fossil fuel industry."

Waypoints
COP31's official end passed yesterday; new drafts expected at 09:00 local time had not appeared
The second draft text was half the length of the first and stripped out most provisions
Panama's letter lists eight requirements, including a cap on oil production
100 NGOs co-signed the letter to presidents Chris Bowen and Murat Kurum
"Transition away from fossil fuels" is absent from the current draft
COP31 officially ended yesterday without a deal, and the talks have dragged into overtime in Antalya with no new draft text in sight. Delegates were told overnight to go home and come back in the morning. Fresh texts were expected at 09:00 local time — that deadline has passed with nothing published.
The hold-up is the familiar one: text. Two drafts have circulated so far. The first included pretty much everything any delegation wanted. The second, at half the length, stripped most of it back out, and negotiators and observers widely read it as a significant retreat.
Who is blocking what?
Panama escalated the pressure on Thursday with a letter to the COP presidency warning it would block any deal that fails to meet its eight requirements — among them real transparency, new rules of engagement and a cap on oil production.
African ministers pushed in the same direction from a different angle, warning the summit that rich countries were undermining the process, trust and credibility of the UN climate negotiations by failing to live up to their commitments under the Paris agreement.
A significant bloc of countries has demanded the phrase "transition away from fossil fuels" return to the text. It is absent from the current draft — and that absence is the single most contested line item still on the table.
What did the 100 NGOs tell the presidencies?
Civil society organisations wrote overnight to COP31's joint presidents, Chris Bowen and Murat Kurum, telling them they had hours left to avoid presiding over "one of the most disappointing Cops the UNFCCC has ever had."
"The Global South is being abandoned," the letter said. "Developed countries have blocked progress across the negotiations and arrived with no new finance commitments."
On the draft cover text, the groups were blunt: it "is a gift to the fossil fuel industry," and "the major cause of the climate crisis – coal, oil and gas – fails to rate a mention."
Their summary of the architecture of the deal: "It has all the hallmarks of a deal to let carbon capture through in exchange for an electrification target that does not even require renewables-based electricity or ensures access for the people who need it most. None of this is defensible."
The letter carries 100 signatories, running from the Africa Just Transition Network to Zero Waste Alliance Ireland, and including 350.org, Climate Action Network, Greenpeace International and WWF. Their specific asks:
- Remove carbon capture targets from the text
- Restore pledges to uphold indigenous peoples' rights
- Add measures holding rich countries accountable for public climate finance
- Explicitly welcome the International Court of Justice's advisory opinion that states have a duty to protect the climate
- Link the electrification goal to renewable generation and a transition away from fossil fuels
That last demand comes with a warning: "Without this link, the target risks supporting additional electricity demand while leaving fossil fuel dependence intact."
The groups also urged the presidencies to carry forward the COP30 roadmap on transitioning away from fossil fuels through to the second Global Stocktake, as a presidency-led dialogue — otherwise, they wrote, "Ethiopia will unfairly be left to carry the burden of your failure into Cop32."
Activists have already labelled Antalya 2026 the "worst Cop ever."
Can one country actually block the deal?
The practical question hanging over Panama's threat is whether a single party can hold up a final decision. The short answer from COP veterans: no.
A final decision requires "consensus" to be gavelled through — but consensus within the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change does not mean unanimity. "No country has a veto," one veteran negotiator said. "It's wrong to think that one country can hold up everything."
The precedent is well established. At Paris in 2015, a handful of countries including Nicaragua, Cuba, Bolivia and Venezuela objected to the final deal; it was gavelled through anyway. India raised objections in the final plenary of COP29 in Baku in 2024, and the deal still closed.
The convention traces back to an early COP in the 1990s, when Saudi Arabia and its Arab Group allies objected to an outcome the rest of the world favoured. They were named in the final text as objecting — and realised they preferred not to be singled out as standing against climate progress again.
As another veteran put it: "All countries feel the impacts of the climate crisis. We are all in this together."
What happens next is simple to state and hard to do: a text has to land, a gavel has to fall, and either "transition away from fossil fuels" is in it or someone gets named.
via theguardian.com (Source)
More from Elena Vasquez
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in Circular economy and the environmental industry at Circular Wire.
575 articles