Compliance & Policy

Cop31 talks stall as 130-nation bloc weighs fossil fuel showdown with Saudi Arabia

Cop31 in Antalya overran into Sunday with no deal, as 130 countries weigh forcing Saudi Arabia into public opposition over fossil fuel phase-out language cut from the draft text.

Climate talks stall as countries mull showdown with Saudi Arabia over fossil fuel phase-out
Climate talks stall as countries mull showdown with Saudi Arabia over fossil fuel phase-outfill / pixabay

Waypoints

  1. About 130 countries demand the 'transition away from fossil fuels' wording be reinstated in the Cop31 final text after it was cut from Thursday's revised draft

  2. Talks scheduled to end Friday overran into Sunday; delegate departures risk breaking the UNFCCC quorum

  3. The fossil fuel language was first agreed at Cop28 in Dubai in 2023

  4. Saudi Arabia wants CCS recommendations in the cover decision; other countries back a 35% electricity share of world energy by 2035

  5. An open-meeting showdown forcing Saudi Arabia to state public opposition is under active consideration

Climate negotiations in Antalya, Turkey, ran into Sunday with no deal, as a coalition of about 130 countries weighed forcing an open showdown with Saudi Arabia and its allies over whether the final Cop31 text must reference a "transition away from fossil fuels."

The fortnight-long summit, run under the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change, was scheduled to close on Friday evening. It didn't. The joint presidencies — Australia and Turkey, in the first dual presidency in Cop history — held meetings with scores of delegations through Saturday night as delegates rescheduled flights.

There's a procedural clock ticking underneath the drama: if enough delegates leave, the conference of the parties may no longer meet the quorum the UNFCCC requires to adopt any decision at all.

What's actually blocking the text?

Three fights dominate, and they're linked:

  • Fossil fuel language. The "transition away from fossil fuels" wording — first agreed at Cop28 in Dubai in 2023 — appeared in the first draft of the Antalya outcome, then was excised from a revised draft published Thursday. On Saturday evening, the EU, the UK, the least developed countries, the small island states and many African countries marched to the presidency's office to demand its reinstatement.
  • Finance. Developing countries want stronger claims on adaptation funding from rich nations, arguing prior pledges remain undelivered.
  • Technology. Saudi Arabia wants strong recommendations on carbon capture and storage in the "cover decision." Other countries object, viewing CCS as a route to perpetuating fossil fuel production. A compromise sketched by some negotiators would downplay CCS and strengthen a proposed target to derive 35% of global energy from electricity by 2035.

Maina Talia, climate minister of low-lying Tuvalu, was blunt about the fossil fuel reference: "This is a red line for us. We're talking about the root cause of all this. [Without it] then we are wasting our time here."

Who's blaming whom?

Mohamed Adow, director of Power Shift Africa, said the meeting feels like it's unraveling: "We came to Antalya needing progress on public climate finance, adaptation and fossil fuels. Instead we are fighting to stop governments retreating from promises they have already made. Rich countries have spent two weeks finding reasons not to deliver the [financial] support they promised."

Campaigners targeted fossil fuel interests directly. Nick Dearden of Global Justice Now said: "This must be the last time we allow fossil fuel interests, which are profiting so handsomely from the climate crisis, to hold us to ransom."

Harjeet Singh, global convener of the Fill the Fund campaign, framed the finance gap as decisive: "You can't ask developing countries to transform their economies while they're drowning in disasters and debt. Whatever deal emerges in Antalya, the world should know why this Cop failed. It wasn't a lack of solutions, it was a lack of money and a lack of will from those who caused this crisis."

How did the process get here?

The dual presidency itself is drawing fire. It exists because both Australia and Turkey bid to host, and last year's compromise split the job between them. Claudio Angelo of the Observatorio do Clima said the arrangement is part of the problem: "It goes to show how a weak presidency, split between two countries with little tradition in climate diplomacy, can be detrimental to a process already victimised by geopolitics."

The fossil fuel standoff has recent precedent. Saudi Arabia and its allies blocked operational progress on the Cop28 language at Cop30 in Brazil, where the hosts sidestepped the impasse by pledging to draft a global phase-out roadmap instead.

What happens next?

One option under active consideration Saturday night, the Guardian understands, is forcing an open meeting where Saudi Arabia and any allies would have to publicly state opposition to the stronger outcome most countries want. It's risky — the tactic could collapse the talks entirely.

Bill Hare, chief executive of Climate Analytics and a Cop veteran, thinks isolation changes the math: "If the overwhelming number of countries here want a strong text, referencing the transition away from fossil fuels and so on, and Saudi Arabia is on its own, I think Saudi Arabia will probably not stand against the global consensus."

China and India, while not part of the 130-country progressive coalition, are reportedly unlikely to block a deal.

The UK's energy minister, Miatta Fahnbulleh, kept the official line open: "We are working closely with partners to find a way through and secure an agreement that moves us forward. These are difficult negotiations, but discussions remain productive and there is a deal to be done."

The milestone to watch: whether a final cover decision lands with the fossil fuel reference intact — and whether enough delegates remain in Antalya to give it a legal quorum at all.

via theguardian.com (Source)

Share this article:

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering technology and product news in Circular economy and the environmental industry at Circular Wire.

575 articles

Nearby routes

« Previous article