Compliance & Policy

Cop31 Collapses as EU Rejects Fossil-Fuel-Free 'Antalya Pact'

Cop31 in Antalya ended with no cover decision after the EU, UK and island states rejected a pact that omitted any mention of fossil fuels. CCS language drew the fiercest fire.

Cop31 climate talks set to collapse as key deal rejected
Cop31 climate talks set to collapse as key deal rejectedMarreKrisu / pixabay

Waypoints

  1. Cop31 in Antalya closed Sunday with no cover decision adopted

  2. EU, UK and 130+ countries demanded fossil fuel transition language absent from the text

  3. Talks ran two weeks, overrunning the Friday deadline into Sunday

  4. Saudi Arabia defended CCS provisions; Africa group, China and Pakistan did not object

  5. Mary Robinson and civil society groups criticised the Turkish-Australian co-presidencies' leadership

Close to 200 countries ended two weeks of talks in Antalya, Turkey, on Sunday without a main climate agreement, after the EU, the UK and developing-world allies rejected a draft pact that never mentioned fossil fuels.

The proposed "Antalya Pact" — the cover decision meant to be the summit's headline outcome — failed to reach consensus. Ireland's environment minister Darragh O'Brien, speaking for the EU, called the text unacceptable in the talks' closing session.

"We will not endorse a decision that does not respond to the science and that actually risks deepening the chasm between global commitments and the action required," O'Brien said. "[It] does not even mention fossil fuels."

His intervention drew applause from the hall. Panama, the Marshall Islands and Norway followed with similar objections. The EU, O'Brien added, would not sign off on a decision "that greenwashes fossil fuels".

The plain takeaway: the world's biggest negotiating bloc walked away rather than bless a text that skipped the sector at the root of the problem.

What was in the rejected text?

The draft, steered by the Turkish and Australian joint presidencies, had three main planks:

  • An invitation for countries to electrify their economies
  • A call for rich nations to fund climate adaptation in poorer ones
  • A push to minimise overshoot of the 1.5C heating threshold set by the Paris agreement

What it lacked mattered more. More than 130 countries had demanded language endorsing a "transition away from fossil fuels" — language that did not survive into the final draft. The text instead carried provisions on carbon capture and storage (CCS), which campaigners argue prolongs fossil fuel use. Saudi Arabia defended the CCS inclusion.

The Africa group, China and Pakistan did not object to the deal, despite reservations from some of them.

How did the talks end without a deal?

The summit, scheduled to close on Friday, dragged into Sunday afternoon through long stretches of stalemate. Turkey's Cop president, Murat Kurum, acknowledged there was no consensus on the cover decision, so the presidencies passed decisions on related procedural matters while dropping the main outcome outright.

"We have done our utmost; ultimately, we have not imposed this text on anyone, nor have we issued an ultimatum such as a 'take it or leave it' demand," Kurum said. "It is clear that there are parties in this hall who oppose this text. We recognise that there is no consensus on this document. Therefore, these decisions have not been adopted."

Who said what in the fallout?

Civil society groups, which hold a mandated role at the talks, declared it the "worst Cop ever". Mohamed Adow, director of Power Shift Africa, was blunt on Friday: "The Cop presidents want to tell us this has been a great Cop. Well, I can tell you without any doubt that this has been the worst Cop ever."

On Sunday, Adow widened the criticism to the EU itself: "The EU has rejected this text, but it cannot wash its hands of the wreckage it helped create... For countries facing failed harvests, destroyed homes and mounting debt, this amounts to abandonment by the wealthy nations most responsible for the crisis."

He added: "Europe's hypocrisy is staggering. Its governments demand fossil fuel roadmaps from others while expanding fossil fuels themselves."

African ministers made their own intervention on Friday, telling the plenary: "We did not come here to beg."

Bill Hare, chief executive of Climate Analytics, read the collapse differently: "This feels like a real line in the sand moment. Countries are standing up to fossil fuel interests and saying no."

Mary Robinson, former president of Ireland and former UN climate envoy, pointed at the process itself as the talks neared their scheduled close. "There isn't the sense of urgency to address these issues. That to me is very frustrating," she said. "We have co-presidents who haven't really been stepping up and giving that leadership."

What happens next?

The negotiations unfolded against a year of extreme weather that has claimed tens of thousands of lives — heatwaves, the glacier collapse in Nepal, and droughts and floods worsened by a supercharged El Niño. Even veteran participants were appalled by the pace.

With no cover decision adopted, the fossil-fuel transition question now carries over unresolved into the next Cop cycle — and the credibility of the 1.5C commitment rides on whether any future text can name the fuel.

via theguardian.com (Source)

Share this article:

More from Daniel Okafor

Daniel Okafor

Show full bio

Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in Circular economy and the environmental industry at Circular Wire.

568 articles

Nearby routes

« Previous article