Compliance & Policy

EU SFDR deal creates three categories and a fossil-fuel compromise

EU’s provisional SFDR overhaul creates Sustainable, Transition and ESG Basics categories, with a 20% taxonomy-aligned capex route for qualifying fossil-fuel expansion.

SFDR 2.0: EU Strikes Deal on New Sustainable Investment Product Categories
SFDR 2.0: EU Strikes Deal on New Sustainable Investment Product Categoriesttomus90 / pixabay

Waypoints

  1. A provisional EU deal announced Thursday creates three SFDR product categories.

  2. Qualifying Transition companies must allocate 20% of capex to EU Taxonomy-aligned activities.

  3. At least 70% of a portfolio must follow the strategy tied to its category.

  4. Transition products must disclose fossil-fuel use and greenhouse-gas emissions as PAIs.

  5. New rules would apply two years after publication in the EU Official Journal.

By Elena Vasquez

A provisional EU deal would let some fossil-fuel companies expanding their operations qualify for a new Transition investment product if 20% of their capital expenditure meets EU Taxonomy alignment tests.

European Parliament lawmakers and EU member states announced the agreement on Thursday. The provisional deal creates three categories for financial products making ESG claims, following a 2023 European Commission review that found investors could mistake the regulation’s existing disclosure tiers for formal sustainability labels.

SFDR has applied since 2021. It governs how financial market participants, including asset managers, disclose the integration of sustainability risks, consideration of adverse sustainability impacts and sustainability information for investment products.

What do the three product categories mean?

The agreement establishes three labels for products making sustainability-related claims:

  • Sustainable: Products already meeting high sustainability standards and contributing to climate, environmental or social goals.
  • Transition: Products investing in companies or projects that are not yet sustainable when those holdings have a credible transition path or contribute to improvements in climate, environmental or social outcomes.
  • ESG Basics: Products that do not qualify for the first two categories but use ESG approaches, including best-in-class selection on a chosen metric or excluding the worst ESG performers.

The category criteria combine exclusions, industries or activities that bar investment, and positive-contribution tests. At least 70% of a portfolio must follow the ESG strategy matching its category.

Why did the EU change the disclosure framework?

The European Commission’s 2023 review said SFDR disclosures were too long and complex, making products hard for investors to understand and compare. It also identified apparent misuse of Article 8 and Article 9 as de facto sustainability labels.

Some investors took Article 9 funds to be necessarily fully sustainable and Article 8 funds to strongly integrate ESG factors, although neither conclusion necessarily followed. The Commission said that mismatch increased the risk of greenwashing.

What does the fossil-fuel compromise require?

The Commission initially proposed excluding companies that expand fossil-fuel activities from both Sustainable and Transition products. The Council and Parliament later took different approaches to Transition funds.

In the Council’s position, the exclusion would disappear in Transition. Fossil-fuel companies would have to allocate 20% of capital expenditure to EU Taxonomy-aligned activities and maintain a clear, time-bound strategy to reduce Scope 1 and Scope 2 greenhouse gas emissions.

Parliament’s position also used a 20% capex threshold but added a stricter capital-allocation test: companies would have to put more money into sustainable activities than into new fossil-fuel projects.

The provisional compromise allows expansion despite those concerns. Qualifying companies would need a clear, time-bound greenhouse-gas reduction strategy aligned with the Paris Agreement, 20% taxonomy-aligned capex and an increasing share of taxonomy-related capital expenditure over time.

For product issuers, that is not a one-time screening exercise. The 20% test equates to $20 of every $100 in capital expenditure, while the rising-share condition requires managers to track whether an issuer’s disclosed transition plan and spending mix improve after launch.

Isabella Ritter, senior EU policy officer at ShareAction, said the change “risks turning the Transition category into a safe haven for fossil fuel companies.”

She added: “A transition category should support companies moving away from fossil fuels, not allow their expansion to continue. This risks undermining the credibility and coherence of the entire framework from day one.”

What must qualifying funds disclose?

Products qualifying for Sustainable or Transition must identify and disclose their Principle Adverse Impacts, or PAIs: negative environmental and social effects associated with their investments. Transition products must include fossil-fuel use and greenhouse-gas emissions among those indicators.

For asset managers, the PAI schedule becomes a mandatory disclosure for qualifying products, with fossil-fuel use and greenhouse-gas emissions specifically named for Transition funds.

Which products gain access or can opt out?

The agreement removes the exclusion of general-purpose issuances by EU-based public-sector bodies from Transition products, subject to conditions. The Council said established EU climate and sustainability commitments make it possible to assess whether those securities align with sustainability objectives.

Allowing them would significantly expand the pool of Transition investments available to insurance and pension funds, according to the Council.

Separately, financial market participants can opt out of the categorization system for alternative investment funds offered exclusively to professional investors. Safeguards would prevent retail investors from indirectly holding such products.

What happens next?

The provisional agreement still requires endorsement by the European Parliament and the Council. The new rules would apply two years after publication in the EU’s Official Journal. Until both institutions endorse the text, the category thresholds, fossil-fuel conditions and retail safeguards remain provisional.

The decisive next step is Parliament and Council endorsement; publication in the Official Journal would then start the two-year implementation clock.

via ESG Today (Source)

Share this article:

More from Elena Vasquez

Elena Vasquez

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering technology and product news in Circular economy and the environmental industry at Circular Wire.

564 articles

Nearby routes

« Previous articleNext article »