Compliance & Policy

CCC warns ZEV mandate cuts would add 8.4m tonnes of CO2 a year

CCC analysis says weakened EV sales rules would add 8.4m tonnes of CO2 a year and probably break the UK's legally binding net zero targets by 2050.

UK will miss climate targets if it weakens EV sales rules, advisers warn
UK will miss climate targets if it weakens EV sales rules, advisers warnandreas160578 / pixabay

Waypoints

  1. CCC says weakened ZEV rules would add an extra 8.4m tonnes of CO2 a year by the next decade.

  2. Carmakers face fines of £12,000 per vehicle under the ZEV mandate's 33% target; EVs were 26.6% of sales in the first ten months of 2026.

  3. Topping warns cuts would cost households about £800 a year and increase oil exposure by 15m barrels a year in 2030.

  4. The UK is unlikely to meet the carbon budget covering 2033-37 under the proposed mandate changes.

  5. Government says it remains committed to phasing out new petrol and diesel cars by 2030 and zero-emission sales by 2035.

Weakening the UK's electric vehicle sales rules would probably cause the government to miss its legally binding climate targets, the Climate Change Committee has warned, with the changes projected to add an extra 8.4 million tonnes of CO2 pollution a year by the next decade.

The analysis by the CCC, published in a letter on Wednesday, concludes the UK is "likely to miss" its climate goals if it confirms plans to allow more sales of petrol and diesel cars and vans over the next four years. The ZEV mandate is the single biggest contributor to those goals, so any reduction leaves ministers hunting for equivalent cuts elsewhere — or amending the carbon budgets to permit more pollution.

The arithmetic is unforgiving. Take the largest decarbonisation policy off the table and the remainder of the net zero plan carries the gap. The committee's view is that it will not carry it.

What is at stake in the mandate?

Carmakers must sell a rising proportion of electric cars each year under the zero emission vehicle mandate, or face fines of £12,000 per vehicle. The industry has lobbied intensively for months to cut the headline targets from 80% electric by 2030 to as low as 50% or 60%, arguing the mandate places them under too much financial pressure.

The market data explains the pressure. Electric cars accounted for 26.6% of UK new car sales during the first ten months of 2026, well below the 33% headline target. Carmakers are nevertheless expected to comply through a series of loopholes known as "flexibilities".

The CCC's chair, Nigel Topping, wrote to Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander to oppose any reduction. Such cuts would, he said:

  • put the government's commitment to tackling climate change at risk
  • miss an opportunity to reduce costs for a typical household by about £800 a year
  • increase UK exposure to volatile oil markets by up to 15m barrels of oil a year in 2030
  • damage long-term competitiveness "as our main export markets rapidly transition to electric vehicles"

How deep does the policy wobble go?

Some in government have grown alarmed in recent months about the cumulative effect of its own changes on the UK's climate commitments. Ministers have just cut funding for heat pump installation — the second-biggest decarbonisation policy. The Prime Minister has also alienated some Labour MPs by waving through gas extraction from the Jackdaw gasfield and considering approval for the massive Rosebank oilfield.

MPs voted earlier this year to approve a new set of carbon reductions covering 2038-42. The Guardian has learned that one cabinet minister wanted the government to return to parliament, scrap those planned reductions and enact a more conservative target instead. The idea failed; other cabinet ministers were mostly opposed.

An industry source with knowledge of discussions in government said serious consideration was still being given to changing the carbon budgets ahead of the UN's Cop31 climate conference, subject to parliamentary approval — though the source said it was not clear whether the proposal remained live. A government source strongly denied it was under consideration.

The mandate changes also mean the UK is unlikely to meet the carbon budget covering 2033 to 2037. Several analysts said the government will struggle to find emissions reductions elsewhere, given the scale of pollution from petrol and diesel cars and vans. The policy could face further opposition from the governments of Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, each of which holds its own carbon budgets.

The irony of the calendar was not lost on observers. The Prime Minister told Cop31 in Antalya, Turkey, on Thursday that he was "proud to support this Cop's focus on electrification" and urged people to choose electric cars and heat pumps.

Doug Parr, chief scientist at Greenpeace UK, said: "The Burnham government cannot talk of climate leadership on the international stage while doing a U-turn on ZEV targets at home."

What do the defenders of the mandate say?

Topping was blunt. "Weakening the zero-emission vehicle mandate would miss an opportunity to reduce the cost of living for people, undermine Britain's competitiveness and leave us more exposed to volatile fossil fuel prices," he said.

"People are buying electric vehicles in record numbers because they are cheaper to own than the alternative. The mandate gives those up and down the supply chain the certainty they need to invest, supports thousands of jobs, and keeps the UK on track to meet its climate commitments. British drivers deserve better than a backtrack on such critical policy."

The car industry rejected the CCC's analysis. Mike Hawes, chief executive of the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, said: "A successful EV transition needs a strong market and a competitive industry. The CCC, however, ignores the damaging cost of the targets it defends: billions in unsustainable discounts and millions more in government incentives."

"Contrary to the CCC's claims, the mandate is deterring local investment, as however much manufacturers export, without a strong local market there is no business case to build here."

A government spokesperson said: "We remain committed to the phaseout of all new petrol and diesel cars by 2030 and to all new car and van sales being zero emission by 2035, as well as to our legally binding net zero targets. Our consultation on the mandate will not change this and will ensure we are taking a pragmatic and balanced approach to the ZEV transition."

What decides what happens next?

Two dates now govern the file: the close of the government's consultation on the mandate, and the point at which any attempt to amend the carbon budgets would need parliamentary approval. Until the first is resolved, the 2030 phaseout pledge and the CCC's 8.4-million-tonne warning sit in open conflict. The consultation outcome will tell us which one bends.

via theguardian.com (Source)

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering regulation, policy and their impact on Circular economy and the environmental industry at Circular Wire.

528 articles

Nearby routes

« Previous article